Syllabus: Journalism 353

Contemporary Issues

Tuesdays and Thursdays, 10:10-12:10 p.m.

Reid 215

 

Instructor:                Wendy Zomparelli

Office:             Reid 118

Office Phone:    (540) 458-8434

Cell:                (540) 556-2345

Email:              zomparelliw@wlu.edu

 

Office Hours:

          Wednesdays, 10 a.m. to noon; afternoon hours by appointment

Tuesday and Thursday hours by appointment

                                                                                     

Required Texts:

n        Writing Opinion for Impact by Conrad C. Fink (Paperback, 384 pages, Blackwell Publishing Limited, 2nd edition, Oct. 1, 2004.)

 

n        Introduction to Reasoning by Steven Toulmin, Richard Keike and Allan Janik (Paperback, 435 pages, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, Oct. 22, 1997.)

 

n        Writing Tools: 50 Essential Strategies for Every Writer by Roy Peter Clark (Hardcover, 272 pages, Little, Brown and Company, Sept. 1, 2006.)

 

Course Objectives:

n        To provide students with practical experience in opinion writing through the exploration of contemporary issues

n        To enable experimentation with other forms of opinion writing, including arts reviews and personal columns

n        To explore the elements of argumentation; to practice building logical arguments and to write them effectively

 

Course Structure:

 

Excellent commentary on the issues of the day requires in-depth grasp of the facts and solid analysis, compellingly written. For that reason, this course will move down two tracks simultaneously. The first spans all 12 weeks: We will discuss the nature, craft and state of opinion writing, with frequent writing assignments based on a range of current topics in the news. “Writing Opinion for Impact” (see “Required Texts,” below) will help provide background for our discussions.

 

The second consists of two special topics, which we will consider sequentially. In the first six weeks, we will explore the elements of argumentation, breaking chains of thought into their components and examining their validity. We’ll be guided by the book “An Introduction to Reasoning,” which uses everyday examples to illustrate the ways in which people typically (and unthinkingly) make claims and assertions, and then try to back them up logically.

 

The second part of track two will be a focus on writing style, guided by “Writing Tools: 50 Essential Strategies for Every Writer.”

 

In general, we’ll spend a portion of each two-hour class on each track. We will also have frequent discussions about issues in the news and about interesting commentaries class members have read. And we’ll talk about new media and the impact they are having on public discourse.

 

By Nov. 10, students will select an issue on which to focus and will submit a final project of three commentaries of 500 to 700 words by Dec. 10. 

 

In addition, the class will agree on an issue for an oral project called “Seeing More Than One Side.” The instructor will frame the issue as a debate topic, and each class member will prepare arguments pro and con. These arguments will be presented orally, in class; students will not be told in advance which side they will be representing. 

 

Readings:

n        Required texts listed above

n        MDR (Minimum Daily Reading Requirement):

o      The New York Times

o       All front-page articles (with jumps and sidebars)

o       Everything on the op-ed pages (editorials, commentaries, letters to the editor, cartoons, the works)

o       Lead article on the Business section

n        Students are encouraged to spend some time each day browsing other news items and commentaries in other publications, radio, TV and on the Web.

n        Additional articles as assigned

 

Course Policies:

 

n       Your success in this course depends not just on what you learn, but what you contribute. For that reason, unless you are ill, I expect you to attend every class.  If you are unable to attend, let me know in advance.

 

n       Class discussions will, I hope, be lively, with conflicting ideas and beliefs among students, the instructor and guest speakers. Students will be expected to maintain a civil and respectful tone at all times. Ideas may be criticized,  but not people.

 

n       We will have several guest speakers during the term; these are busy people who are making a gift of their time. Come prepared to ask them questions, to pay attention and to be responsive.

 

n       All assignments must be turned in on time.  Late assignments will be docked a full letter grade for each day (or part of a day) that they are late.  

 

n       Accuracy is essential. Your assignment will receive an F if you misspell a proper name (individual, organization, country, etc.), get a key fact wrong or exhibit faulty math.

 

Grading:

n       Quizzes: 20 percent

n       Final individual project: 25 percent

n       Final class project:  10 percent

n       Other written assignments: 35 percent

n       Professionalism, attendance and class participation: 10 percent

 


 

Journalism 353: Contemporary Issues

 

 

Key:

n        WOI = Writing Opinion for Impact

n        IR = Introduction to Reasoning

n        WT = Writing Tools: 50 Essential Strategies for Every Writer

n        NYT = The New York Times

n        WSJ = The Wall Street Journal

 

All writing assignments are due by 10 a.m. on the dated noted, unless otherwise announced. Other writing assignments may be added.

 

This syllabus may be modified to take advantage of the presence of guest speakers on campus, or because of developments in the news, or for other reasons. Any changes to the assignments posted here will be announced at the end of each class. A revised syllabus may be distributed midterm.

 

 

Week

 

Date

 

Topic

Reading Assignment

for the next class

 

Writing Assignment

1

Thursday, Sept. 6

n       Brief intro of students, instructor

n       Course objectives and expectations

n       News v. opinion: intro, discussion, terms

 

n     Handouts on Loudon Co. immigration debate

n     IR, pp. 3-27

 

Due Tues., 9/11: Personal commentary on immigration policies in  Loudon County (250-500 words)

2

Tuesday, Sept. 11

n       Forms of commentary

o       Discussion: Who are your favorite columnists/commentators? Why?

n       Arguing v. argumentation

n     WOI, pp. 3-19

n     IR, pp. 29-44

n     Columnist TBA

 

 

 

Thursday, Sept. 13

n        Feedback on writing assignment

n        Mission and ethics of opinion writing

n        Anatomy of an argument: Claims

n     WOI, pp. 23-60

 

Due Thurs., 9/20: Personal commentary on Virginia’s civil fines for drivers

3

Tuesday, Sept. 18

n        Institutional opinion: How editorial boards work

o        The role of the publisher, owner

n        Before class, read the day’s editorials in WSJ

n        IR, pp. 45-77

 

 

 

Thursday, Sept. 20

n        Anatomy of an argument: Backing

n        Guest speaker: Dan Radmacher, editorial page editor, The Roanoke Times

n        WOI, pp. 65-94

n        IR, pp. 81-101

 

4

Tuesday, Sept. 25

n        Choosing and reporting topics

o         Can you add value to the discussion?

o         Point of view

n        Claims, backing: How strong are these elements in today’s NYT, WSJ editorials?

n        Before class, read the day’s editorials in WSJ

n        IR, pp. 103-128

 

.

 

Thursday, Sept. 27

n        Class exercise: You’re the editorial board

o         Finding common ground

o         Seeing more than one side

n        IR, pp. 129-149

Due Tuesday, 10/2: Based on the board’s decisions, each student will write one editorial of 500 words

5

Tuesday, Oct. 2

n        Meeting readers’ needs, anticipating their desires

o        New media formats

o        Changes in media usage trends

o        Responding to reader complaints and criticisms

n        Fallacies in arguments

n        IR, pp. 151-179

 

 

 

Thursday, Oct. 4

n       Feedback on students’ editorials

n       Fallacies in arguments (cont’d)

n       IR, pp. 393-421

n       Articles on candidates and issues in election for Rockbridge County Board of Supervisors

 

6

Tuesday, Oct. 9

n       Editorial endorsements: how and why

 

n       WOI, pp.123-156

n       Continue readings on Rockbridge elections

 

 

Thursday, Oct. 11

Fall Reading Day – No classes

 

 

7

Tuesday, Oct. 16

n        Class exercise: You’re the editorial board (part II)

o        Election endorsements

 

n        TBA

Due Monday, 10/22: Based on the board’s decisions, each student will write an endorsement editorial of 500 words

 

Thursday, Oct. 18

n        Introduction to personal columns

n       Ethics and Reasoning

n      Packet of columns by  Shanna Flowers

 

8

Tuesday, Oct. 23

n       Guest speaker: Roanoke Times columnist Shanna Flowers

 

n     WT, pp. 3-55

n     WOI, pp. 159-182

 

 

Thursday, Oct. 25

n       Summary on personal columns

n       Discussion of first 10 Writing Tools

n       WT, pp. 59-116

 

Due Fri.., 11/2: A 700-word  column that connects something in the news to something in student’s personal experience

9

Tuesday, Oct. 30

n        Discussion of students’ endorsement editorials

n        Discussion of “Special Effect” tools

n        WOI, pp. 221-247

 

 

Thursday, Nov. 1

n        Writing Reviews

n        Selection of reviews TBA

 

10

Tuesday, Nov. 6

n       Discussion of assigned reviews

n       Continued discussion of writing tools

n       TBA

Write a review of a student performance TBA

 

Thursday, Nov. 8

n       Discussion of students’ personal columns

n       Discuss selection of a topic for final individual and class projects

n       Selection of blogs TBA

Due 11/10: Brief description of the issue you are going to do your project on

11

Tuesday, Nov. 13

n       Final selection of class project topic for “Seeing More Than One Side”

n      Each students assigns one favorite blog

n      WOI, pp. 253-296

 

Due 12/10: Final project of three commentaries of 500 to 700 words each. 

 

Thursday, Nov. 15

n       Blogs

n        WT, pp. 195-244

 

 

12

Nov. 19-23

Thanksgiving Recess

 

 

13

Tuesday, Nov. 27

n       Discussion of students’ reviews

n       Discussion of “Useful Habits”

n        TBA

 

 

Thursday, Nov. 29

n       “Seeing More Than One Side” – Part I

 

 

14

Tuesday, Dec. 4

n       “Seeing More Than One Side” – Part II

 

 

 

Thursday, Dec. 6

n       Wrap-up