| |
Hampden H.
Smith's remarks upon receiving the George Mason Award for
outstanding contributions to Virginia journalism by the Richmond
Professional Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists. |
|
I’m
sorry Jerry Finch is not here. He was my boss at the News Leader –
yes, in addition to my other talents, I’m an orphan – and wrote
about me recently that I was one of the few journalists he knew who
could run a Ludlow. The Ludlow is a machine from the hot-metal,
Linotype days of printing that was used to create headlines and
other big type. I literally wrote most of the hedes for the News
Leader and Times-Dispatch during the printers’ strike in the early
‘70s. He sorta implied, in classic Finch wry humor, that being a
Ludlow operator was my major claim to journalistic competence. When
I referred to that comment, he responded that I was confused: It was
not Ludlow, but Luddite,.
When I
told him nearly 30 years ago that Washington and Lee had offered me
a job teaching journalism rather than doing it, I was of course
expecting he’d urge me to stay at the newspaper. No. I should take
it, he said. I’m glad I did. I’ve been saved from total paper
purgatory by having been lucky enough to play journalist on the copy
desk of the Philadelphia Inquirer for something like 20 years.
As a
teacher, I have learned far more about what journalists do – or
should do – than I did as a practitioner. Teaching gives you time
to think, and to read – and the job description includes the
expectation that you say things that sound profound. So, in a scope
broader than, say, reporting on an issue before City Council, I’ve
had to try to grasp and then explain what is so special about the
job we do – to persuade students and critics that a free society
depends on a vigorously free press, that the public cannot possibly
assess the institutions of society without our independent
reporting.
It was in
Moscow that I was getting the hang of explaining this – or at
least I like to think so. It was 1992. The Berlin Wall had just come
down; the Soviet Union had disintegrated; Russia was toying with a
responsible public and a responsive government – neither of which
had Russia ever had before – and maybe doesn’t even yet. I was
on a Fulbright lectureship in the journalism faculty at Moscow State
University. My Russian students could mouth the First Amendment
quicker than my American students, but they had not the slightest
idea of its implications. Write critically of government? Oh, I
couldn’t do that!, they’d say.
Russia
taught me the necessity of establishing overarching ideals or goals
and then seeing how we might reach them. What is the goal of a free
society? What are the responsibilities of a representative
government? Of the public to be informed? Of the press to
accurately, fairly, aggressively report and write about how well the
world works? I learned that important things really are very
important, and that details are only that. The world got a lot
simpler – a few big things, and a huge pile of relatively
insignificant matters handled without much debate once the major
issues – the really important goals – are understood.
No.
It’s not always that easy. I was in Baku, Azerbaijan, to talk to
journalists there shortly after the government was trying to
intimidate the opposition press by having goons beat up aggressive
reporters. And in one case, a high-ranking official stabbed a
reporter in the eye with a pencil – blinding the reporter for a
story the government didn’t like. We agreed that a journalist’s
first responsibility was to write stories so they could expect to
live to write another one.
Another
benefit of teaching is it’s easy to pretend immortality. Students
are a teacher’s immortality. The Dick Amhrines. The Rob Hedelts
– don’t blame me for his spelling, though. The Irina Dmitrievas,
a student at Moscow State University, now a media lawyer in Chicago.
The Marc Santoras, at age 25 or so, writing elegantly and
compassionately from Iraq for the New York Times. The Mike Allens
– when someone tells me about a Washington Post story that really
eviscerates the administration on some embarrassing issue, I know
exactly who wrote it before seeing the paper.
The
ideals of George Mason are among those few concepts that we
journalists honor every day – I hope – in our work. His
declaration of rights, approved June 12, 1776, was humankind’s
first authoritative formulation of the doctrine of inalienable
rights. Thomas Jefferson was strongly influenced by Mason’s
ideals, and the Declaration of Independence clearly reflects
Mason’s principles and perspectives. He condemned slavery “disgraceful
to mankind.”
Mason’s
enumeration of rights is the first article in the Virginia
constitution, not amendments tacked on at some later date.
His
first section deals with Equality and rights of men. “That
all men are by nature equally free and independent and have certain
inherent rights, of which, … they cannot, by any compact, deprive
or divest their posterity.”
His
second declares people are the bearers of value in a free society:
“That all power is vested in, and consequently derived from, the
people, that magistrates are their trustees and servants.”
And his
third, “That government is, or ought to be, instituted for the
common benefit, protection, and security of the people … and,
whenever any government shall be found inadequate or contrary to
these purposes, a majority of the community hath an indubitable,
inalienable, and indefeasible right to reform, alter, or abolish
it.”
In
Section 12 he deals with the fundamental role that free speech and
press play in society: “That the freedoms of speech and of the
press are among the great bulwarks of liberty, and can never be
restrained except by despotic governments.”
You
can see, I am certain, why I am so profoundly grateful to be honored
by an award named for this man. And another thing: It is my
understanding that a cabal of former students conspired in my
nomination. To Mr. Potter and his co-conspirators, may I say, there
is no higher honor than to be remembered in this way by one’s
former students and, now, friends.
|